Iraq elections
The one thing I can say about the Iraq elections is that I hope they mean something. While I fully disagree with the war, I do hope that these elections empower the people there and bring about real change. I fear, though, that they won't, because there is complete chaos there among the various ethnic/political factions and there hasn't been much done to address that. Throwing democracy their way doesn't make those problems go away.
And, whatever the results, will we be happy with the outcome if the new people in power hate us? If people we like get power, will they ever be able to shake the image of being U.S. puppets? These are the problems of going in, fighting a war, occupying a country and deposing its leader, and then setting up a democracy with parameters. We decided all of this, they didn't. Legitimacy is a big question.
And, of course, the other big questions are, when do we leave, and will the chaos ever end?
But, Iraqis going to the polls at the risk of their own lives will be, undoubtedly, a powerful statement. They will have displayed more courage than anyone in the U.S.--including its leaders--can imagine. How many of us would go vote if we thought there was a chance we would be killed?
And, whatever the results, will we be happy with the outcome if the new people in power hate us? If people we like get power, will they ever be able to shake the image of being U.S. puppets? These are the problems of going in, fighting a war, occupying a country and deposing its leader, and then setting up a democracy with parameters. We decided all of this, they didn't. Legitimacy is a big question.
And, of course, the other big questions are, when do we leave, and will the chaos ever end?
But, Iraqis going to the polls at the risk of their own lives will be, undoubtedly, a powerful statement. They will have displayed more courage than anyone in the U.S.--including its leaders--can imagine. How many of us would go vote if we thought there was a chance we would be killed?
